Whereas we (though we'd often like to think we are immune) are very much
part of the world economy, we have to conform to popular demand, at
least to some degree, in order to get anything published. In an ideal
society, everyone finds the perfect union of popular demand, interest,
and talent. But, unfortunately, we do not live in an ideal society, and
I think it's important for us to remember a few things:
1) Great breakthroughs and trends often start slowly. Einstein was in
poverty when he made some of his first breakthroughs- and it took quite
a while before anyone else realized the magnitude of his ideas (in other
words, even after his ideas were starting to be disseminated, he
REMAINED in poverty). Another example is Mozart, but the list could go
on to include many other great thinkers who not only had to come up with
their ideas, but they had to show others the power of their ideas- they
had to market them!
2) Despite the "rational" trend of secularization, the world is
inevitably heading towards (if it isn't already there) increased concern
over issues of faith, morality, and ethics. Open discussion and
consideration of such issues are what make academics such a wonderful
profession to be in (as long as protection from closed-mindedness,
extremism and fanaticism continues). Given that the world is headed for
increased discussion on topics of Spirit and Religion, it is very likely
that popular demand for this class of dialogue will increase
dramatically in the coming years- though this demand may take a little
while to get going...
Having said that, I agree with what has already been said: It's
possible, but rare, that someone who truly pursues her/his interests
with full courage and capacity, will regret it in the long run- either
financially or professionally.
Shaun Hansen
-----Original Message-----
From: Management, Spirituality & Religion [mailto:
MSR@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU]
On Behalf Of Dr. Fry
Sent: Sunday, September 17, 2006 7:42 PM
To:
MSR@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
Subject: Re: Career Advice for People Interested in MSR
My basic response is that good solid research will get published in peer
reviewed journals. And , it is already clear to me that good journals
(e.g.,
The Leadership Quarterly, which is currently rated 9th in management and
6th
in psychology based on citations and downloads) are willing to publish
good
MSR research. We also have our own journal, JMSR, that is publishing
ever
better quality quantitative and qualitative MSR research. The real
question
then becomes at what type of institution do you want to work and what
are
their standards for success? For example, Tarleton State University is a
second tier school that has a strong emphasis on teaching. All anyone
has to
do here, researchwise, is have a few hits in SOME peer reviewed journals
and/or national or regional meeting proceedings.
On the other hand, if you want to be in the top tier schools like Texas
A&M
and The University of Washington (where I had tenuer), you'll have to
hit
the top 5 journals to get tenure. Right now JAP, AMJ, and AMR are a
stretch
for our field (I'm trying my best to change that). This is nothing new.
When
I came out of Ohio State in 1978 I had offers from both Texas A&M and
The
University of Texas. However, OB was a relatively new field and I was
told
at Texas that a publication in AMJ wouldn't count (The wanted stuff in
Management Science). Therefore, I chose Texas A&M where my friend Don
Hellriegel (Top OB book with John Slocum and a past Academy president)
was
then Department head.
So I don't think you have to compromise anything to have a successful
career
that emphasizes MSR. The key to this is the same as in any spiritual
quest:
Know thyself, seek transcendence through purpose, and find a community
where
you can be accepted, appreciated, and loved unconditionally. Take this
journey in faith and the rest will take care of itself.
Louis W. (Jody) Fry
Professor of Management
Tarleton State University - Central Texas
1901 South Clear Creek Road
Killeen, Texas 76549
254-519-5476
----- Original Message -----
From: "Ekaterina Zhuravleva" <
ekaterina_zhuravleva@HOTMAIL.COM>
To: <
MSR@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU>
Sent: Sunday, September 17, 2006 12:53 AM
Subject: Re: Career Advice for People Interested in MSR
> Don,
> this is a very timely topic for me. I am a PhD student completing my
> dissertation in Australia. I have just received permanent residence
visa
> to Canada and will be moving there within the next year. I started the
job
> search and I didn't find any vacancy associated with MSR stream. At
this
> point my main focus is on finding like-minded people, and see whether
I
> can find jobs at their universities. And then of course, it is about
OB
> lecturing or something like that. I guess junior faculty doesn't have
a
> luxury at this point to be hired on the MSR position (and are they
> there?). So, I would consider myself lucky if I could find a job at
the
> Uni that gives a chance to research in this area and to work with
senior
> academics who belong to MSR stream.
> Would love to hear from all of you.
>
> Also I would to take this chance to say hello to everyone I met in
> Atlanta. It was an honour to meet all of you. I am blessed to having
> started working in the area which gets me connected to so talented and
> beautiful people.
>
> Cheers from Sydney,
> Katya Zhuravleva
>
>
>
>
>
>>From: Don McCormick <
don_mccormick@REDLANDS.EDU>
>>Reply-To: "Management, Spirituality & Religion"
<
MSR@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU>
>>To:
MSR@AOMLISTS.PACE.EDU
>>Subject: Career Advice for People Interested in MSR
>>Date: Fri, 15 Sep 2006 12:26:17 -0700
>>
>>Hi All
>>
>>I just received a request for career advice from a new doctoral
student
>>interested in MSR. I'm not sure what to tell him.
>>
>>I have a colleague who is well known in the field of psychology of
>>religion. He tells students who are interested in that field that
there
>>are almost no jobs in the field of psychology of religion. People
>>interested in it should have a main focus in an area where people do
get
>>hired (for example, social psychology) and a secondary interest in
>>psychology of religion. Then, once they get tenure, they can switch
and
>>make psychology of religion their major focus.
>>
>>Would you say this advice holds for people interested in MSR? Or is
it
>>really off base? What has been the experience of those of you who
read
>>this list who did dissertations on an MSR topic and did a job talk on
>>that topic? The Academy job listings have almost no listings for MSR
>>positions, so how did you decide what openings to apply to?
>>
>>- Don
>>---
>>Don McCormick, Ph.D.
>>2030 Overland Avenue
>>Los Angeles, CA 90025
>>
dwm2@cwru.edu
>>(310) 470-2492
>>http://newton.uor.edu/FacultyFolder/DMcCormick/Site/Welcome.html
>>
>>
>